Cradle Score
Health & safety · Last checked Sep 30, 2026

Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Nighttime Pacifier

BudgetLow confidence

Verdict

A breast-like nighttime pacifier that passed every Consumer Reports lab test.

SiliconeBreast-like shape

What parents and testers say

Recurring praise

  • Passed lab tests

Recurring complaints

  • Few independent reviews

Our summary of patterns across the reviews and threads linked below. Not quotes.

Materials & safety check

✓Lab testsPassed Consumer Reports' lead, phthalate, nitrosamine and bite tests
✓RecallsNone found in CPSC pacifier recalls since 2020

When to buy it

Registry

Add 2–3 shapes; babies have preferences

After birth

If breastfeeding, many wait until feeding is established

Ongoing

Replace at any tear or stickiness; never tie to a cord

Consider instead: Avent Soothie for newborns.

Sources

  1. Consumer Reports: Best pacifiers based on lead, phthalate and durability tests
  2. CPSC recall database: "pacifier" recalls since 2020

Spot something wrong or out of date? Email [email protected] and we'll recheck it.

More health & safety, scored

Philips Avent Soothie PacifierThe one-piece hospital pacifier: cheap, easy to sterilize and low on nipple confusion.About $2 eachMedium confidenceToddleroo by North States Stairs GateA hardware-mounted stair gate with no bottom bar to trip on, one-hand opening and a stop that keeps it from swinging over the stairs.About $50Low confidenceVicks SpeedRead Digital ThermometerA cheap stick thermometer that's about as accurate as it gets and works rectally, which pediatricians recommend for young infants.About $15Low confidenceMAM Original Matte PacifierSymmetrical silicone nipple with an anti-slip surface and a sterilizer case.BudgetMedium confidenceItzy Ritzy Sweetie SootherOne-piece food-grade silicone in fun colors, dishwasher safe, and passed Consumer Reports' tests.BudgetMedium confidence

See all 25 in Health & safety →